| Emma | Potter | Noblesville | 2021 | Central Michigan (Verbal) |
| Ava | Wetzel | Carmel | 2020 | University of Indianapolis |
| Sarah | Meek | Bishop Chatard | 2020 | University of Detroit Mercy |
| Maddie | Ash | Penn | 2020 | Marian |
| Taylor | McNally-Henriksen | Zionsville | 2020 | Hanover |
| Masi | McNally-Henriksen | Zionsville | 20202 | Hanover |
| Megan | Heneman | Carmel | 2020 | Hope |
| Abbie | Nutter | Zionsville | 2019 | Hope |
| Allison | Sturgeon | Harrison | 2019 | Norwich University |
| Victoria | Simmons | Carmel | 2019 | Franklin |
| Kaija | Kunttu | Zionsville | 2019 | Akron |
| Lora | Atkins | Carmel | 2019 | Franklin |
| Chloe | Harding | St. Joseph | 2019 | UC - Colorado Springs |
| Maddie | Dumke | Carmel | 2019 | Marian |
| Chloe | Foley | Penn | 2019 | Grand Valley State |
| Maddie | Donlon | John Glen | 2019 | Notre Dame College (OH) |
| Bri |
Lloyd |
HSE |
2019 |
Heidelberg |
| Izzy | Corns | Bishop Chatard | 2019 | Savannah College of Art & Design |
| Aerin | Fortune | Westfield | 2019 | Aurora |
| Gretchen | Reeves | Cathedral | 2018 | Hanover |
| Emma | Kennedy | Bishop Chatard | 2018 | Depauw |
| Milah | Young | Marian | 2018 | Hanover |
| Kate | Hettiger | Carmel | 2018 | Augustana |
| Lindsey | Traub | Bishop Chatard | 2018 | Lewis |
| Kelly | Csenar | Carmel | 2018 | Lincoln Memorial |
| Jess | Turner | Culver | 2018 | Detroit - Mercy |
| Kaylee | Riggins | Zionsville | 2018 | LIU- Brooklyn |
| Kate |
Burnside |
Cathedral |
2018 |
UC Boulder |
| Hannah | Potter | Noblesville | 2017 | Central Michigan |
| RJ |
Johnston |
Zionsville/Franklin TN |
2017 |
Transylvania |
| Katie | Stordy | Guerin Catholic | 2017 | DeSales |
| Jordan | Blackburn | Culver | 2017 | Earlhan |
| Becca |
Broadwick |
Penn |
2017 |
Lee University |
| Sydney | Blake | Zionsville | 2016 | Depauw |
| Bri | Hart | St. Joe's | 2016 | Central Michigan |
| Zoe | Law | Park Tudor | 2016 | Butler |
| Kate | Flynn | Cathedral | 2016 | Depauw |
| Maddie | Allen | Park Tudor | 2015 | Depauw |
| Sydney | Allen | Park Tudor | 2015 | Otterbien |
| Rachel | Allen | Bishop Chatard | 2015 | Depauw |
| Morgan | Bolden | Cathedral | 2015 | United States Naval Academy |
| Meredith | Doron | Zionsville | 2015 | Edinboro |
| Anna | Kitchen | Carmel | 2015 | LaSalle |
| Nico | Polhamus | Penn | 2015 | Army- West Point |
| Rory | Byrne | Culver | 2014 | Notre Dame |
| Kelsi | Carr | Culver | 2014 | Hobart-William Smith |
| Hailey | Hallenback | Park Tudor | 2014 | Butler |
| Emma | Flynn | Cathedral | 2014 | Depauw |
| Jayme | Brizzolara | Zionsville | 2013 | Aquinas |
| Erin "Koko" | Kunkle | Zionsville | 2013 | Belmont Abbey |
| Kelsey | Johnson | Park Tudor | 2013 | Baldwin- Wallace |
| Izzy | Tuminello | Park Tudor/ISI | 2013 | Dennison |
| Bailey | Meador | Heritage Christian | 2013 | Liberty |
| Gabriel | Nondorf | Bishop Chatard | 2013 | Baldwin- Wallace |
| Jenna | Turner | Carmel | 2013 | Baldwin - Wallace |
| Olivia | Rabbit | Culver | 2013 | Elon |
| Mary Ann | White | Cathedral | 2012 | Dennison |
| Hope | Thomas | Carmel | 2012 | Lock Haven |
| Alyssa | Stetson | Carmel | 2012 | SCAD |
| Caroline | Kraus | HSE | 2012 | Grand Valley State |
| Sarah | Lankton | Guerin Catholic | 2012 | Findley |
| Ashley | Parry | North Central | 2011 | Wooster |
| Molly | Maher | Zionsville | 2011 | Marymount |
| Rachel | Ward | Bishop Chatard | 2011 | Lock Haven |
| Grace | Garrett | Carmel | 2011 | Trine |