Next Step Sports Academy hires experienced coaches to run each sport specific program. Below is a list of coaches who have worked for NSSA over the past three years.
| Baseball | | |
Stephen DellaRovere
| Nipmuc Varsity Baseball Head Coach | |
| Basketball | | |
| Brittany Kahler | BVT Girls Varsity Basketball Head Coach | |
| Jessica Grady | Former Nipmuc Girls Varsity Basketball Head Coach (former) | |
| Cheerleading | | |
| Ashley Picard | Former Boston Celtics Cheerleading | |
| Field Hockey | | |
| Bill McInnis | Former Nipmuc Girls Varsity Field Hockey Head Coach | |
| Molly Smith | Former Nipmuc Girls JV Field Hockey Head Coach | |
| Hockey (floor/street) | | |
| Greg Labossier | Hopedale Boys Varsity Hockey Head Coach | |
Lacrosse
| | |
| Chris Hadfild | Nipmuc Girls Varsity Lacrosse Head Coach (former) | |
| Softball | | |
| Jessica Grady | Nipmuc Girls JV Softball Head Coach (former) | |
Volleyball
|
| |
| Brian Gerrard | Nipmuc Boys/Girls Varsity Volleyball Head Coach (former) | |
|
| |