Shetland 6U baseball is tailored for children aged 4, 5, and 6, introducing them to the basics of baseball in an enjoyable setting. Players learn fundamental skills like hitting, fielding, and base running, fostering a positive first encounter with the sport. This division combines machine pitch and Tee Ball, with four machine pitches per at-bat followed by hitting from the tee if needed. The pitching machine is set at 20 mph, ensuring an appropriate level of challenge for young players as they develop their skills.

Pinto 8U baseball is a youth baseball program tailored for children aged 6, 7, and 8. In this division, young players further hone their foundational skills while deepening their understanding of the game. They receive instruction in advanced techniques of hitting, fielding, pitching, and base running, with a focus on enhancing individual abilities and fostering teamwork. Unlike earlier divisions, Pinto 8U involves keeping score and participating in playoffs, where seeding is determined by teams' performance in the regular season. This division utilizes machine pitch, with the pitching machine calibrated to deliver pitches at 40 mph. Batters face six pitches per turn, and failure to hit a fair ball results in an out.

Mustang 10U baseball is a youth baseball program tailored for children aged 8, 9, and 10. In this division, young players further develop their skills while transitioning to "MLB rules," gaining insights into the game's strategies and subtleties. Featuring player pitch, participants learn essential techniques like taking lead-offs, stealing bases, and executing pickoffs. Competitive gameplay is a highlight, with teams tracking scores and vying for playoff spots based on their season performance.

Bronco 12U baseball is a youth program tailored for kids ages 10, 11, and 12. In this division, players continue to refine their skills and deepen their understanding of baseball's intricacies. Following standard MLB rules, the playing field dimensions are larger than younger divisions, aiding the transition to middle school ball. Base paths extend to 70ft, and the mound is set 50ft from the rubber to the back of home plate. Competition intensifies, with teams keeping score and vying for playoff spots based on their regular-season performance. Bronco 12U baseball fosters skill development and teamwork in a more competitive setting.

Pony 14U baseball is a youth baseball program tailored for players ages 13 and 14. In this division, players experience an adjustment in pitching distance, moving to 54 feet, while bases extend to 80 feet, in preparation for high school baseball. The game adheres to standard MLB rules. Participants engage in a more competitive atmosphere, focusing on advanced tactics, teamwork, and honing individual skills. Pony 14U baseball serves as a platform for young athletes to enhance their capabilities and gear up for elevated levels of competition.

The PONY League Champions Division is a specialized baseball program designed to provide opportunities for players with special needs to participate in the sport. It is specifically tailored for individuals who may face challenges that prevent them from participating in traditional baseball or softball programs. The Champions Division focuses on creating a supportive and inclusive environment where players of all ages and abilities can enjoy the game of baseball. It typically emphasizes friendly, non-competitive play, prioritizing fun and camaraderie above winning or skill level.