| First Name | Last Name | Class | High School | College |
| Matthew | Agudelo | 2020 | Pingry High School, NJ | Drew University, NJ |
| Demi | Amigun | 2020 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark ,NJ | George Washington University, DC |
| Jayson | Argueta | 2020 | Bloomfield High School, NJ | Rutgers University – Newark, NJ |
| Massimo | Banfi | 2020 | Morristown Beard, NJ | Fordham University, NY |
| Matthew | Casqueira | 2020 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark ,NJ | Caldwell University, NJ |
| Cao | Chaves | 2020 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark ,NJ | Jacksonville University, FL |
| Lui | Chaves | 2020 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark ,NJ | Caldwell University, NJ |
| Dominick | Commesso | 2020 | Morristown Beard, NJ | Fordham University, NY |
| Andrew | Garofalo | 2020 | Montclair Kimberley Academy, NJ | Widener University, DE |
| Nicholas | Janusz | 2020 | | |
| Ian | Kagan | 2020 | Chatham High School, NJ | Franklin & Marshall College, PA |
| Israel | Neto | 2020 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark ,NJ | Caldwell University, NJ |
| Sebastian | Niehenke | 2020 | Seton Hall Prep, West Orange, NJ | Bates College, ME |
| Alexander | Pina | 2020 | North Bergen High School, NJ | New Jersey City University, NJ |
| Joao | Portella | 2020 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark ,NJ | Florida Gulf Coast, FL |
| Connor | Querrard | 2020 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark ,NJ | Assumption College, MA |
| Thiago | Quintanhila | 2020 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark ,NJ | Spring Hill College, AL |
| Jamar | Ricketts | 2020 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark ,NJ | University of California (Berkeley), CA |
| Preston | Rushmore | 2020 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark ,NJ | Robert Morris University, PA |
| Andrew | Sanay | 2020 | Union City High School, NJ | Rutgers University – Newark, NJ |
| Michael | Sanchez | 2020 | | |
| Andre | Schiavone | 2020 | Randolph High School, NJ | University of Tampa, FL |
Class of 2019 |
| First Name | Last Name | Class | High School | College |
| Henrique | Cruz | 2019 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | University of Akron, OH |
| Thiago | Franca Ribiero | 2019 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | St. Vincent's College, PA |
| Maxwell | Gibson | 2019 | North Star Academy, Newark, NJ | Rutgers-Camden University, NJ |
| Julian | Gomez | 2019 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Monmouth University, NJ |
| Azriel | Johnson | 2019 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Salt Lake CC, UT |
| Dylan | Ladda | 2019 | Montclair Kimberley Academy, NJ | College of Charlston, SC |
| Charlie | Maslag | 2019 | Rutherford High School, NJ | |
| Alex | Oliviera | 2019 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Fairfield University, CT |
| Jose | Pena | 2019 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Stevens Institute, NJ |
| Celio | Pompeu Martins | 2019 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Virginia Commonwealth University, VA |
| Jason | Ricca | 2019 | Bloomfield High School, NJ | NJIT, Newark, NJ |
| Eduardo | Richa | 2019 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | St. Vincents College, PA |
| Julian | Tellez | 2019 | PCTI, Wayne, NJ | Rutgers University – Newark, NJ |
| Sebastian | Varela | 2019 | Ramapo High School, NJ | Layfayette University, PA |
| Mark | Walter | 2019 | Westfield High School, NJ | Muhlenberg College, PA |
Class of 2018 |
| First Name | Last Name | Class | High School | College |
| Max | Blacker | 2018 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Brandeis University, NJ |
| Igor | Blasque | 2018 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Returned to Brazil |
| Sebastian | Chalbaud | 2018 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Stetson University, FL; High Point University, NC |
| Francisco | Corral | 2018 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Georgian Court University, NJ |
| William | Dukevicz | 2018 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Kean University, NJ |
| Dillon | Konzelmann | 2018 | New Providence High School, NJ | Kean University, NJ |
| Luan | Lamas | 2018 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Fairfield University, CT |
| Nicholas | Linebaugh | 2018 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Rutgers University – Newark, NJ |
| Felipe | Lucas | 2018 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Kean University, NJ |
| Jozef | Magiera | 2018 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Rowan University, NJ |
| Massimo | Mazzella | 2018 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Elizabethtown College, PA |
| Brian | Pacceli | 2018 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | St John's University, MN |
| Davi | Silva Alves | 2018 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Rutgers University – Newark, NJ |
Class of 2017
|
| First Name | Last Name | Class | High School | College |
| Joseph | Alba | 2017 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Iona College, NY; Rutgers University - Newark, NJ |
| Nico | Black | 2017 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Fairfield University, CT |
| Lucas | De Moraes | 2017 | Eastside High School, Newark, NJ | Rutgers University – Newark, NJ |
| Nicholas | Devasia | 2017 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | St. John's University, MN |
| Manuel | Fragapane | 2017 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Spring Hill College, AL |
| Allen | Gavilanes | 2017 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Marist College, NY |
| Mickey | George | 2017 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Eastern Florida CC, FL |
| Matthew | Moreno | 2017 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Spring Hill College, AL |
| Adonis | Scotland | 2017 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Rutgers University - Newark, NJ |
| Louis | Silva | 2017 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Georgian Court University, NJ |
| Diogo | Veloso | 2017 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Florida International University, FL |
Class of 2016 |
| First Name | Last Name | Class | High School | College |
| Johnny | Antunes | 2016 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Monmouth University, NJ |
| Joao | Cadima | 2016 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Mercer County College, NJ |
| Fabio | DeSousa | 2016 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Rutgers University – Newark, NJ |
| Camilo | Fuentes | 2016 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Rutgers University – Newark, NJ |
| Esteban | Hidalgo | 2016 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Georgetown University, MD |
| Michael | Lescano | 2016 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Stockton University, NJ |
| Darnell | Lopez | 2016 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Stockton University, NJ |
| Andy | Martinez | 2016 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Monmouth University, NJ |
| Andres | Medina | 2016 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Rutgers University – Newark, NJ |
| Joey | Meyer | 2016 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Fairfield University, CT |
| Ernest | Mitchell | 2016 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Marist College, NY |
| Jose | Monzon | 2016 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Rutgers University – Newark, NJ |
| Malcolm | Morreira | 2016 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | New Jersey City University; Kean University, NJ |
| Christian | Nunez | 2016 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | FDU Teaneck, NJ |
| Rodrigo | Saldana | 2016 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Union County College, NJ |
| Victor | Villagomez | 2016 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Bergen Community College, NJ |
Class of 2015 |
| First Name | Last Name | Class | High School | College |
| Anderson | Asiedu | 2015 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Monmouth University, NJ; UCLA, CA |
| Joe | Burgos | 2015 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Farleigh Dickinson University, NJ; NJCU, NJ |
| Rui | DeOliveira | 2015 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Princeton University, NJ |
| Jean | Derival | 2015 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Returned to Haiti |
| Wilber | Nunez | 2015 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | St. Peter's College, NJ |
| Juan | Parada | 2015 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Eastern Florida CC, FL Marsit College, NY |
| Auro | Patnaik | 2015 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Lock Haven University, CT |
| Zachary | Perreira | 2015 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Monmouth University, NJ |
| Jovan | Poggi | 2015 | St. Benedict's Prep, Newark, NJ | Felician College, NJ |